The ’08 Sox are behind the ’07 Sox, record-wise, after the first four dozen games.
Last year’s club had a 33-15 record, with 25 quality starts pitched at this point. The team was 19-6 when the starter earned a QS. Starter’s ERA was a collective 3.93 in 297 2/3 innings pitched. The club had an impressive 11 game lead over the second place Blue Jays (22-26) after 48 games last year.
The ’08 team is 29-19, with 25 quality starts, with a 17-8 record in those games. The starter’s have pitched fewer innings (287 1/3 IP) and have a slightly lower ERA (3.92). The Sox have a 1 game lead over Tampa at this point.
QUALITY START REPORT ANALYSIS
REASON #1: OFFENSE
The offense in 2007 had a slightly better start, scoring 13 more runs over the first 48 games. Not a huge difference. So what, do I hypothesize, makes up for the 4 game difference in record? The bullpen and defense have both been down a bit over 2007. Is that enough for a four game difference? Well, maybe. Here is a little bit more detail on “run prevention”. In 2007, through 48 games, the Sox had allowed only 183 runs, 130 were earned runs allowed by the starters. This year’s club, has allowed 210 runs, 27 more in total, and more than a half a run per game. The starters have allowed 125 earned runs, a smaller total then the ’07 team. So, where are the other runs allowed? The bullpen and errors.
REASON #2: Improved AL EAST (except the NYY)
Another issue is that the division is better. The Sox have been swept on the road by the Rays, Orioles, and Blue Jays already in 2008. That accounts for 8 of the 19 losses right there. The Sox have lost 8 quality starts all season, seven of those losses are in the division. A split in those games, certainly conceivable and possibly even disappointing by 2007 standards, and the ’08 club would be level with the ’07 start. That being said, and thinking back to the games in Toronto, the Trop, and at Camden, what is the one issue that pops into mind? BULLPEN. Followed in a close second by poor run production by the offense, that certainly sputtered against the strong Jays staff at the end of the first road series (yeah, remember, 3 countries) and then again against the improving Rays staff (5 runs in 3 games) at the end of April.
A possible REASON #3: The defense.
I am not convinced of a ‘fatal’ flaw in the defense, as was noted in 2004 by Theo, but it is something that I am going to keep an eye on. Julio Lugo has certainly been the source of most errors by the team, which seems otherwise quite sound defensively. The bullpen has truly been troubling at times, especially shortly after the Japan trip. An improving Craig Hansen, a stable Manny Delcarmen, and a healthy Jonathan Papelbon and Hideki Okajima over the next couple of months will certainly help get the Sox a comfortable AL East lead.